That being said, I tend to have an opinion somewhere between the majority of college students and the professors interviewed in the article. While I do believe that effort should be factored into grades, as it seems only fair that students applying themselves and devoting time and energy to a class should see some reward, I also agree with the professors that A's should be earned and simply doing the bare minimum of what is required should not necessarily guarantee a good grade. I mean, even from kindergarten we learn that an A implies excellent work that surpasses required expectations, or something to that effect. I would venture to guess that many students, though, especially at bright universities like UNC, have been able to excel in school and earn A's without putting forth all of their effort. Thus this sense of entitlement that the professors in this article discuss is born; we students come to expect A's by putting forth the same amount of effort as we have been all of our lives. What we must learn, perhaps, is that college is a whole new level of academia designed to prepare us for real life and requires more effort to secure the grades we are accustomed to.
I think the special seminars suggested towards the end of the article are a creative, good idea to try and shift the paradigm of learning towards to become more "holistic and intrinsically motivated." It may take a while, but learning does need to move in that direction because in real life you are not judged or graded all the time, or at least not in the same sense as an academic environment. For us to succeed post-college we really need to learn to shirk the stigma of grades and numbers and develop an inherent love of learning.
No comments:
Post a Comment